pittsburgh tasty reviews

Customer Testimonials

We are proud to have been a small part of our customer’s celebrations, birthdays, weddings and other special occasions. A few reviews from our satisfied customers from the past 20 years.

I’ve been wanting to let you know just how much we enjoyed the wedding cookies you did for us. They were absolutely the best cookies I’ve ever had at a wedding.  We had so many compliments and people asking where they were from. Well done. We will be back for holiday cookies. Thx again for making my daughters wedding so special!!
Mrs. Kuhn (Pittsburgh, PA)

I wanted to tell you that your cookies were absolutely delicious. You are a wonderful baker. A true professional. Since I do a lot of baking as well, I’m very picky. So glad I found someone I can count on. Thank you again.
Jeannette (Pittsburgh, PA)

I feel that cookies and food are the most important things at a wedding reception so I just wanted to thank you for making us the BEST cookies ever! Because of your perfectionism and talent, the cookie table had a beautiful display of mouth-watering, eye appealing desserts that were truly a big hit with our guests! Our guests did not hesitate to take the left over cookies home with them as we had planned. The only sad part was that we did not have many cookies to take home and enjoy ourselves!
Thank you again for everything!!!!
Roberta D. (McDonald, PA)

I wanted to thank you for the amazing wedding cake and the delicious cookies.  Everybody raved about the cake and it looked amazing.  People were so happy to take some of your cookies home with them.  You do an amazing job and I just wanted you to know how much we appreciate your time and talent.  Take care!
Mary Beth M. (Pittsburgh, PA.)

We loved Oliver's birthday cake.... it was delicious! All guests agreed. Oliver could not stop looking at the cake and yes, stuck his finger in to test....his brother, Christian - age 4 also stuck his finger in the cake and both said, "This is good!". Thank you, Debbie, for a job well done.....cake was both great looking and delicious!
Janice L. (Pittsburgh, PA)

Wow!!!! Stunning, Beautiful, Elegant cake!!!! It’s more than I could have ever imagined! We loved it!!!!
Lots of compliments not only how gorgeous the cake looked (masterpiece) but how delicious it was. Deb.... you out did yourself on the cake and cookies. I never saw such perfection!!!!
Sandy and George W. (Pittsburgh, PA)

I cannot put into words how I feel about Deb's cakes....delicious, scrumptious, the best I have ever had.  Ever since I tasted her almond cake with buttercream icing I have been hooked. I actually crave and have dreamt about her cakes. I recently asked Deb to make a 50th b-day cake for my fiancee' and let me tell you.... I loved it! My guests kept complimenting not only how great it was decorated but wanted to know who made the delicious cake. I am sooo excited Deb is making my wedding cake and cookies. Deb is a perfectionist you wouldn't know that by talking with her. She takes her time with you, never did I feel rushed when going over the details of my wedding. What can I say.... I love Deb,her cakes and cookies!
Sandy P. (Pittsburgh, PA)

Sometimes if you're really lucky you can actually get what you pay for. Debbie's cookies not only exceeded our expectations but made us some new friends! When our family celebrated my son's graduation from high school we placed our trust in a good friend's recommendation, and Debbie's Deluxe Cookies did not disappoint. The cookie trays looked like bouquets of flowers...each one beautiful and fresh. We actually received notes from more than one of our guests thanking us for inviting them to our celebration. ..they said it was an experience just to taste so many unique cookies. Thank you, Debbie for helping us make our party memorable! The Ward Family, Pittsburgh, PA

buddy valastroWhile attending Buddy's book tour, my daughter Talia got a chance to meet and show Buddy some of my cake pictures. He told Talia that her Mom has a great talent and a great attention to detail in her cake designs!!


Fabulous is the only way to describe Deb’s cookies and specialty cakes! I have been a loyal customer for over 20 years and it is the quality and service that will keep me a loyal customer for the next 20 years. Deb’s delicious desserts have been enjoyed by my family and friends for all of our special events including  holidays, weddings, graduations, communions, birthdays and are even a wonderful way to say ”thank you” to someone. Deb continues to come up with new creations for her product line giving her costumers a variety of selections to choose from. Most important is the time that Deb is willing to spend with me to ensure that each and every order that I place meets the expectation for the event. As a customer, you can count on quality, availability, consistency, dependability, and presentation! Trust me….you will be hooked after your first order!
Lisa B. (Pittsburgh, PA.)

Debbie’s cookies and cakes are always fresh. Everything she makes is absolutely delicious!
Amy N. (Upper St. Clair, PA.)

We use Deb for all our occasions. She made our wedding cake and cookies, she even has a seperate one for our 1 year anniversary, made my Christmas cake for my mangers meeting, and cookies for the nurses that took such good care of me. It all tastes so good and looks amazing.
Christine and Buzz (Muse, Pa.)

We love Debi's cakes!! She seems to outdo herself with every cake she makes! She is very happy to help even at the last minute. We can't wait to see what new creation she comes up with next for us!
Michele (Meadows Racetrack and Casino, PA.)

Hi Deb, I just wanted to thank you again for a great job you did on the cake and the cookies. I'm still getting compliments on how beautiful the wedding cake was. Everything really tasted great. People were busy taking pictures of the cake. They kept telling me that they've never seen a cake done up with a beach theme.
Joanie (Pittsburgh, PA)

Deb Tonti’s cookies and cakes are absolutely delicious. The cookies are always a hit when served at parties and I always get questions about the beautiful cakes. Deb is very friendly and personable. She always makes sure everything is exactly how you ordered it.
Beverly P. (Pittsburgh, PA.)

Just wanted to thank you for helping us when we were lost!!!! Also, wanted to let you know so many people complemented on the cakes, they loved how they were decorated and loved how YUMMY they were!!!!!! The dessert was delicious and a huge success also. I am so glad I decided to order the cookie platter, it was needed and of course the cookies were out of this world!!! I sat your business cards and they were gone and I also told everyone that you are at the farmers market. Thank you again for everything and I look forward to doing business with you again!!
Kim (Pittsburgh, PA.)

What can I say about  Debbie's Deluxe Cookies and Cakes? "You just have to experience her pastry delights!" I patronized her company on many occasion, for gifts, graduations, parties and even funerals. Every time I presented the hosts with her beautiful decorated sweet baked goods, the only thing they could say, "where did you get these cookies and cakes?, from Debbie's Deluxe Cookies and Cakes in Muse, Pa." The next time I"ll have to order more, because they don't last long. One time I was at Nemacolin Woodlands Resort and the bellman ask if he could pass on a cash tip, if I can give him some of Debbie's cookies. Debbie awes everyone with her God given talent.
Dennis M. (West Palm Beach, FL.)

Debbie's bakery products are exemplary! We have had the occasion to sample both her cookies and cakes. Presentation is professionally done; intricately decorated, with attention to detail. It's obvious the creations are done in a state of the art professional bakery, not a mass-product producing store bakery! There's such a difference that you will never go back to buying store-bought! And the taste and freshness are always tantalizing and satisfying. We look forward to each time we have the chance to taste her delicious baking!
Margie & Nick M. (Canonsburg, PA.)

It’s hard to describe Debbie’s cookies, cakes, nut rolls and specialty items in a few words but the first thing that comes to mind is OVER THE TOP! I have been ordering from Debbie for over the last 15 years or so for holidays, birthdays and various other functions and can honestly say all of our family and friends were so impressed that my wife tried to take credit for the baking, but to no avail.
Our son recently graduated from high school and my wife and I needed some guidance on our ordering. Debbie met with us for well over an hour (and several phone conversations), for all of our options and we gave her a general idea of what we wanted; a traditional graduation cake, jello salads, and cookies and to surprise us if she had any other ideas. Well I can tell you surprised does not even begin to describe the desserts, pastries, jello salads, cookies and specialty cakes she prepared and all within our budget. The presentation of the desserts were a sight to behold and the quality was second to none. Not only did Debbie receive several orders from guests at our party for their upcoming events, but our caterer was so impressed with her work that he wanted to meet her and discuss using her services as well. I can write a novel about her work but to sum it up all I can say is try it once and your hooked!
Angelo T. (Houston, PA.)

If you haven't tried a dessert, cake or cookie from Debbie Tonti you have no idea what your missing. Twenty five years ago Debbie made my wedding cake and it was so incredible that we ended up eating the top of the cake the very next day instead of saving it for a year! The cake was so pretty and exactly what we wanted and had the best icing and flavor. I know that over the years Debbie's business has grown, but the attention to detail and flavor always comes first. My boys love her cake icing, it is their favorite as much as mine. And if you get to the farm market on route 50 in South Fayette early enough you should stop by and pick something up from her, you will definitely go back for more or place an order for yourself or next party!
Tracey V. (Bridgeville, PA.)

cookie tray promo